Many new parents are unaware of what an important purchase a diaper pail is. Diapers are messy and have a bad smell, so choosing the best diaper pail can be a very important nursery purchase. When buying a diaper pail, consider how much capacity you want your bin to hold, how strong you want odor control to be, and whether you are using a cloth or disposable diapers, A diaper pail will help keep things smelling fresh and keep the nursery neat and tidy.

 Choosing the best diaper pail for your family and home doesn't have to be another thing to worry about before the baby arrives. We have compiled a list of the Top Ten Diaper Pails currently available on the market to make the decision easy for you. Let's dive into finding the right diaper pail for you.

Comparison Table

Diaper Pail FAQ

Choosing the best diaper pail isn't something one does very often. So what is a diaper pail? What does it do? Below we have a few quick answers about the basics of diaper pails to help you better understand why buying the best one diaper pail is an important decision.

baby legs

Image Source: Pexel


1. What Is a Diaper Pail?

A diaper pail is a special garbage can used to hold soiled baby diapers and wipes.

 

2. What Does a Diaper Pail Do? 

A diaper pail will not only hold soiled diapers and wipes, but it will also control the odor from those diapers and keep you and your family from having to be reminded of dirty diapers each time you walk into the room.

 

3. Where Can You Buy Them?

Diaper pails are available at many large retail stores such as Target and Walmart. They are also available online at retailers like Amazon. Amazon having the widest selection and best prices more often then not.

How We Reviewed

The following diaper pails were reviewed based on Features, Pros & Cons, Price, and Where to Buy them. We invested extensive time and effort into researching all the different makes and models of diaper pails currently available on the market so we could provide a truly unbiased list of best diaper pails. 

Overall Price Range of the Best Diaper Pail

The best diaper pail can often be found in a large array of prices, along with many different features. The price range of the best diaper pail ranges from about $ to $$. This not only depends on the make and model you choose, but also where you buy it from. Often the best deals can be found online at sites such as Amazon. While pricing varies heavily, the best diaper pail provides some same basics.

Such as being a place to store dirty diapers, and some form of odor control. While more expensive diaper pails may offer extra benefits, such as an internal way to cut the diaper pail bag, extra odor control, or even internal mechanisms to push diapers down for you. The best diaper pail is often one that can control odors for long periods of time.

baby standing

Image Source: Pexels

What We Reviewed

  • Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail
  • Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
  • Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail
  • Ubbi Steel Odor Locking Diaper Pail
  • Odorless Cloth Diaper Pail by Busch Systems
  • Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe
  • The Diaper One N Done
  • Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
  • Tommee Tippee Simplee Diaper Pail

Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail, Fully Assembled, with Odor...
  • ALL IN ONE DIAPER PAIL - Diaper Genie's ultimate diaper disposal system controls odors and makes changing your baby's...
  • BUILT IN ANTIMICROBIAL - Upgrade your nursery with Diaper Genie. The Complete Pail includes built-in Antimicrobial that...
  • KEEP YOUR NURSERY FRESH - Unlike other pails without clamps, the Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite Clamps that...

Features

The Playtex Diaper Genie Complete arrives assembled in the box with a 7-layer bag already installed, the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete can hold up to 270 used diapers, making it perfect for use by families with multiples or more than one child in diapers.

This diaper pale is designed to be hands-free the Diaper Genie also comes with a carbon filter in the lid to control bad odors. The bags can be removed via a front tilt bin. The ease of the design and the effectiveness of the odor control helped the Diaper Genie to win the 2018 Women’s Choice Award as America’s Most Recommended Diaper Pail.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Can hold 270 diapers at a time
  • Comes pre assembled
  • Has a foot pedal to open it

CONS

  • Must use specific bags with it
  • Doesn't "twist" the bag after each diaper insertion

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
  • Create the freshest nursery with the STEP diaper pail, proven #1 in odor control. Material-Plastic
  • Get a pail, give a tree -- for every diaper pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree
  • Self-sealing system -- seals the bag shut as the lid closes

Features

The Munchkin diaper pail has a sleek profile, making it stand apart from other diaper pails. Just over two feet tall and has a step mechanism to open the life for you. This diaper pail also uses an internal bag to collect dirty diapers and seal away odors. It has a unique twist technique after closing of the lid to seal the bag, reducing odors further.

This diaper pail is compatible with a wide array of diaper pail bags. The Munchkin diaper pail also uses Arm & Hammer baking soda "pucks" to help with odor control.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$.

PROS

  • Compatible with multi-pul brands of bags 
  • Lid opens by foot step
  • Use of baking soda "pucks" further reduces odor

CONS

  • Lid must be pushed down
  • Diapers must be hand pushed down into the bag

Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to Use | Just Step –...
  • Totally Hands-Free: Step, Drop, Done! No Bending, No Twisting, No Squishing, Unlike Ordinary Pails!
  • Most Cost-Effective Diaper Pail Refill System on the Market. Dekor Refill System Creates Less Waste - Use ONLY What You...
  • Effective Triple Odor Control Keeps the Smell in the Pail

Features

Similar to the Diaper Gene, this diaper pail is hands free, allowing users to open it via a foot pedal. It controls odor by its spring loaded OdorKeeper trap door, this seals diaper in tight. It also uses a powder-scented Dekor Classic refill bags.

To change out bags, users use an internal child safe cutter mounted to the front of the service door. Users then tie a knot at the bottom of the bag

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Internally mounted cutter 
  • Scented bags help control odor
  • Only holds about 45 diapers per use

CONS

  • Only Dekor bags can be used
  • Only holds about 45 diapers per use

Ubbi Steel Odor Locking, No Special Bag Required Money Saving,...
  • SAVE MONEY - NO NEED TO BUY SPECIAL BAGS: No special bags, refills or inserts are required with the Ubbi diaper pail...
  • MOST AWARD WINNING DIAPER PAIL: The Ubbi diaper pail won NINE awards proving parents and experts approval
  • STEEL LOCKS IN ODOR: Unlike plastic, steel is not porous and keeps the smell shielded inside

Features

The Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail is one of the highest rated units on the market. Ubbi uses steel instead of plastic, reducing odors, along with rubber seals at all the joints to trap odors. This diaper pail allows you to use any bag you like, including standard kitchen bags.

The lid slides open on this pail, making it easy to uses when one handed. It has baby proof knobs, preventing small children from opening it up. Emptying it is easy, all you have to do is lift the lid ring, then simply remove the bag.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$.

PROS

  • Easy to use one handed
  • Can use any bag you like
  • Made of less porous steel to prevent odors

CONS

  • No foot pedal
  • Smell is released when diaper pail is opened

Thirsties Diaper Pail Liner, Fin
  • Elastic opening provides a snug fit on most diaper pails up to 54 quarts
  • Waterproof PUL and fully-taped waterproof seams prevent leaking and wicking and keep moisture out of your diaper pail
  • Sewn-in closure strap keeps odors in when liner is not in a diaper pail

Features

Thirsties Diaper Pail is made from recycled plastic and features a seven gallon container made for cloth diaper use. It has a wide opening that is secured by a durable lid. It also has two large handles making it easy to carry to the laundry room. This diaper pail can be used with cloth diaper bags or without. It holds around 2 days worth of solid cloth diapers and keeps odors in check with a carbon filter in its lid.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$.

PROS

  • Doesn't require bags    
  • Has handles for carrying convenience

CONS

  • Plastic tends to absorb the diaper odors
  • Lid does not provide a seal for odors

Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe, Hooray for Grey
  • Superior Odor Control
  • Easy to Use
  • Large capacity holds up to 30 diapers

Features

The Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe is small and available in multiply colors. This diaper pail is unlike its competitors in that users drop the diaper in a cup in the center of the lid and then pull an exterior handle to dump the diaper in the bag. This is what makes this diaper pail essentially odorless.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Perfect for small spaces
  • Comes in three colors
  • Diapers aren't exposed each time pail is opened

CONS

  • Not hands free
  • Due to size, bag must be changed often

The Diaper One N Done
  • Easy to use Diaper Pail
  • Individual diapers are sealed
  • Frame can hang from a changing table or stand alone on a table top.

Features

The supporting frame of the Diaper One N Done can be secured to the side of a changing table, or stand alone on a tabletop. A diaper is thrown in the bag, the bag is sealed with a knot, and a new bag can be pulled from the bottom over the lid of the bucket.

Instead of having a separate large container to store diapers, this system lets you use your existing garbage can. The Diaper One N Done is substantially smaller than many other diaper pails. It combines a perforated roll of bags, much like those little doggie clean-up bag rolls. You open a new bag and put it over the pail edges. Then you put a dirty diaper in, tie it, rip the bag off the roll, and put a fresh new bag over the edge. Then you throw the bagged diaper into your regular garbage can.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Space saving
  • Can use your existing garbage can
  • Attaches to a changing table

CONS

  • Individual bags can be tedious to use
  • Each bag only holds a single diaper

Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
  • Easy one-hand use
  • Uses standard plastic bags
  • Dorizer disc included. Replacement discs sold separately (23900). Warning: proposition 65 reasons:titanium dioxide,...

Features

The  Easy Saver diaper pails lets you use your own tall kitchen garbage bags (the 13-gallon ones), so you don't need to buy separate refills. It also includes a baking soda deodorizer disk that fits into the underside of the top flap. The design is sleek and simple, and the mechanism is high quality and reliability.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Baking soda disc for odor control   
  • Can use your own garbage bags
  • One hand use

CONS

  • Must be hand closed
  • Diapers are hard to push in
  • Opening is small

Tommee Tippee Simplee Diaper Pail Starter Set, Blocks Odor,...
  • Multi-layer film and smart seal lid blocks all odors^Film contains antibacterial ingredient that kills 99% of germs^Each...

Features

The TommeeTippee diaper pail is made of high quaility material. This company is known for producing high quality, reliable, safe products that are inexpensive. It uses a ring shaped refill cartridge, two layers of odor control with a lid you pop open and a small flap you then push the diaper through. However, this unit does require you to open the top by hand.

Price  

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.

PROS

  • Two layers of odor protection
  • Inexpensive

CONS

  • No foot pedal
  • Must use Tommee Tippee brand refill bags

The Verdict

Based on our own research, we found that the best diaper pail for your budget, functions, and connivance was the Playtex Diaper Gene Complete. With its relatively low price point and long list of features, anyone would be glad to own this diaper pail. The Playtex Diaper Gene Complete provides hand free opening, comes already fully assembled when purchased online or in stores, and can hold up to 270 stinky diapers; meaning you spend less time changing out yet another garbage bag each week. 

Coming in at around $ from Amazon makes this one of the less expensive diaper pails available for purchase right now. The bottom line with the Playtex Diaper Gene Complete is that is is an essentially odorless diaper pale that requires little time, effort, or thought. The best diaper pail is one that allows a new parent less time worrying about that diaper smell, and more time spent bonding with your new baby.